Yes, it was an enjoyable two hours, but when I found myself looking forward to the next question on the Who Wants to be a 'Milllllare' (as Anil Kapoor chooses to pronounce it) just so I could try to answer it myself, I realized something wasn't perfect. Don't get me wrong, I am not saying it was a bad movie, it wasn't - especially for a director who is not a mumbaiite, it is quite commendable. The little flashbacks in the police station where Jamal grows from a young boy into a man even before you realize it was a brilliant strategy. However, some of them like the 'Benjamin Franklin' one failed to seem plausible. Why would a young, blind, illiterate boy (Arvind) care to ask who the man on the dollar bill was and further yet how would he know his name? I did not know that Benjamin Frankin was on the dollar bill and I am sure most of my peers wouldn't either and I did my entire schooling in India.
The female lead character who played Latika, was very pretty and looked very Indian despite being Hispanic. I did think that her character as the third musketeer should have been developed better. All that I saw of the relationship between Jamal and Latika, before they left for Agra, was at best two children playing together. Yes, Jamal invited her to share their shelter when it was raining, but they were little children and love at first sight does not exist at that age and more so when they had just lost their parents. That action was clearly that of pity and even if they had grown closer over the relatively brief part of their childhood that they spent together, I didn't feel like Jamal -had- to go back and find Latika.
Salim, Jamal's brother, on the other hand was an excellently played character. The actors who played him at different ages, all fit the character and one another perfectly. Jamal himself was a very subdued character, unsurprising for someone who went through all of that in less than a decade. Yet, I liked Jamal. He seemed like a good guy, a guy a girl could fall in love with, a guy who would not trample over others for anything.
Another issue I had with the film is the way the Police unrealistically let Jamal off, no false cases? No attempts to make some money? Come on, with a guy as recently famous and as rich as Jamal, surely they would expect something for holding him in questioning for a night. Irrfan Khan, as the cop, didn't really have much to do. I love him as an actor, but this wasn't his best performance. The other fat, short cop on the other hand, always plays such a good bombay cop! I loved him!
All in all, a must-see movie for every Indian, because it will make you feel good and proud that you are Indian(Even though it doesn't show the best of India, you know what I mean - you will love that an (essentially) Indian movie has made it huge in Hollywood!). As for people of other ethnicities, despite everything I said - it still is a great movie and I would recommend you watch it, just once though!
P.S - Sorry, I translated the title into Tindi(Tamil+Hindi) because I don't really know the word for slum in Hindi! Educate me?!

11 comments:
I have not yet watched the movie :P But a slum is called Jhopadpatti/Basti in Hindi :P:P
lolz. thts is one funny title. havent seen movie yet, but hav heard rave reviews about it.
Haha, it isn't a very good review..i wrote it at 5 am because I couldn't sleep
Btw, thanks - now i know a new word in Hindi! Yay..lol
and it's kutta..not kutha..lol.
so did i...heard weird reviews .. but havent watched it yet!
come on appu! it is kutha! not kutta!
Kupam Nai LMAO=)) I can appreciate the tile very much ha ha ha ha !!
Haven't watched the movie yet , but heard its good !!
Thanks for the good write-up. Freida Pinto is a konkani speaking model who lives in Mumbai. Her parents are from Mangalore.
She is not hispanic
Sudhir
Another one
There is a good possibility that a blind boy who is in the business of begging, identifies dollar bills through the pictures.. Indian, UK etc have currencies of different sizes, a blind beggar in Mumbai would be able to identify the denomination of the notes through the size. American bills are of the same size (now even the Courts have asked the Department of treasury to print blind friendly notes).
We can conjecture that foreign nationals give $1 or $10 to beggars. Some of these boys are intelligent enough to fold the note and ask a kid to describe the picture…And they find out the denomination of the dollar bill. It sounds strange but it could be true. In Mumbai, around 10 years back I had my shoes polished by a blind shoeshine boy in one of the rail stations. Not only did he do a good job, but gave me and others the correct change.
On a lucky day, the blind beggars may make a killing when someone gives a $100….Remember it is easy for a guy who is drunk to mistake a 100$ bill for a 10$ bill. They all look the same – size and colour.
Also, Boyle and co would have done a reality check of each answer!
lol NO! it's kutta! i use it 179 times a day! lol! :D
Benjamin Franklin is on the $100 bill, not the $1 bill.
George Washington is on the $1 bill.
Post a Comment